Home | History | Annotate | Download | only in imagediff
      1 // Copyright 2013 The Chromium Authors. All rights reserved.
      2 // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
      3 // found in the LICENSE file.
      4 
      5 #include "tools/imagediff/image_diff_png.h"
      6 
      7 #include <stdlib.h>
      8 #include <string.h>
      9 
     10 #include "base/logging.h"
     11 #include "build/build_config.h"
     12 #include "third_party/libpng/png.h"
     13 #include "third_party/zlib/zlib.h"
     14 
     15 namespace image_diff_png {
     16 
     17 // This is a duplicate of ui/gfx/codec/png_codec.cc, after removing code related
     18 // to Skia, that we can use when running layout tests with minimal dependencies.
     19 namespace {
     20 
     21 enum ColorFormat {
     22   // 3 bytes per pixel (packed), in RGB order regardless of endianness.
     23   // This is the native JPEG format.
     24   FORMAT_RGB,
     25 
     26   // 4 bytes per pixel, in RGBA order in memory regardless of endianness.
     27   FORMAT_RGBA,
     28 
     29   // 4 bytes per pixel, in BGRA order in memory regardless of endianness.
     30   // This is the default Windows DIB order.
     31   FORMAT_BGRA,
     32 
     33   // 4 bytes per pixel, in pre-multiplied kARGB_8888_Config format. For use
     34   // with directly writing to a skia bitmap.
     35   FORMAT_SkBitmap
     36 };
     37 
     38 // Represents a comment in the tEXt ancillary chunk of the png.
     39 struct Comment {
     40   std::string key;
     41   std::string text;
     42 };
     43 
     44 // Converts BGRA->RGBA and RGBA->BGRA.
     45 void ConvertBetweenBGRAandRGBA(const unsigned char* input, int pixel_width,
     46                                unsigned char* output, bool* is_opaque) {
     47   for (int x = 0; x < pixel_width; x++) {
     48     const unsigned char* pixel_in = &input[x * 4];
     49     unsigned char* pixel_out = &output[x * 4];
     50     pixel_out[0] = pixel_in[2];
     51     pixel_out[1] = pixel_in[1];
     52     pixel_out[2] = pixel_in[0];
     53     pixel_out[3] = pixel_in[3];
     54   }
     55 }
     56 
     57 void ConvertRGBAtoRGB(const unsigned char* rgba, int pixel_width,
     58                       unsigned char* rgb, bool* is_opaque) {
     59   for (int x = 0; x < pixel_width; x++) {
     60     const unsigned char* pixel_in = &rgba[x * 4];
     61     unsigned char* pixel_out = &rgb[x * 3];
     62     pixel_out[0] = pixel_in[0];
     63     pixel_out[1] = pixel_in[1];
     64     pixel_out[2] = pixel_in[2];
     65   }
     66 }
     67 
     68 }  // namespace
     69 
     70 // Decoder --------------------------------------------------------------------
     71 //
     72 // This code is based on WebKit libpng interface (PNGImageDecoder), which is
     73 // in turn based on the Mozilla png decoder.
     74 
     75 namespace {
     76 
     77 // Gamma constants: We assume we're on Windows which uses a gamma of 2.2.
     78 const double kMaxGamma = 21474.83;  // Maximum gamma accepted by png library.
     79 const double kDefaultGamma = 2.2;
     80 const double kInverseGamma = 1.0 / kDefaultGamma;
     81 
     82 class PngDecoderState {
     83  public:
     84   // Output is a vector<unsigned char>.
     85   PngDecoderState(ColorFormat ofmt, std::vector<unsigned char>* o)
     86       : output_format(ofmt),
     87         output_channels(0),
     88         is_opaque(true),
     89         output(o),
     90         row_converter(NULL),
     91         width(0),
     92         height(0),
     93         done(false) {
     94   }
     95 
     96   ColorFormat output_format;
     97   int output_channels;
     98 
     99   // Used during the reading of an SkBitmap. Defaults to true until we see a
    100   // pixel with anything other than an alpha of 255.
    101   bool is_opaque;
    102 
    103   // An intermediary buffer for decode output.
    104   std::vector<unsigned char>* output;
    105 
    106   // Called to convert a row from the library to the correct output format.
    107   // When NULL, no conversion is necessary.
    108   void (*row_converter)(const unsigned char* in, int w, unsigned char* out,
    109                         bool* is_opaque);
    110 
    111   // Size of the image, set in the info callback.
    112   int width;
    113   int height;
    114 
    115   // Set to true when we've found the end of the data.
    116   bool done;
    117 };
    118 
    119 void ConvertRGBtoRGBA(const unsigned char* rgb, int pixel_width,
    120                       unsigned char* rgba, bool* is_opaque) {
    121   for (int x = 0; x < pixel_width; x++) {
    122     const unsigned char* pixel_in = &rgb[x * 3];
    123     unsigned char* pixel_out = &rgba[x * 4];
    124     pixel_out[0] = pixel_in[0];
    125     pixel_out[1] = pixel_in[1];
    126     pixel_out[2] = pixel_in[2];
    127     pixel_out[3] = 0xff;
    128   }
    129 }
    130 
    131 void ConvertRGBtoBGRA(const unsigned char* rgb, int pixel_width,
    132                       unsigned char* bgra, bool* is_opaque) {
    133   for (int x = 0; x < pixel_width; x++) {
    134     const unsigned char* pixel_in = &rgb[x * 3];
    135     unsigned char* pixel_out = &bgra[x * 4];
    136     pixel_out[0] = pixel_in[2];
    137     pixel_out[1] = pixel_in[1];
    138     pixel_out[2] = pixel_in[0];
    139     pixel_out[3] = 0xff;
    140   }
    141 }
    142 
    143 // Called when the png header has been read. This code is based on the WebKit
    144 // PNGImageDecoder
    145 void DecodeInfoCallback(png_struct* png_ptr, png_info* info_ptr) {
    146   PngDecoderState* state = static_cast<PngDecoderState*>(
    147       png_get_progressive_ptr(png_ptr));
    148 
    149   int bit_depth, color_type, interlace_type, compression_type;
    150   int filter_type, channels;
    151   png_uint_32 w, h;
    152   png_get_IHDR(png_ptr, info_ptr, &w, &h, &bit_depth, &color_type,
    153                &interlace_type, &compression_type, &filter_type);
    154 
    155   // Bounds check. When the image is unreasonably big, we'll error out and
    156   // end up back at the setjmp call when we set up decoding.  "Unreasonably big"
    157   // means "big enough that w * h * 32bpp might overflow an int"; we choose this
    158   // threshold to match WebKit and because a number of places in code assume
    159   // that an image's size (in bytes) fits in a (signed) int.
    160   unsigned long long total_size =
    161       static_cast<unsigned long long>(w) * static_cast<unsigned long long>(h);
    162   if (total_size > ((1 << 29) - 1))
    163     longjmp(png_jmpbuf(png_ptr), 1);
    164   state->width = static_cast<int>(w);
    165   state->height = static_cast<int>(h);
    166 
    167   // Expand to ensure we use 24-bit for RGB and 32-bit for RGBA.
    168   if (color_type == PNG_COLOR_TYPE_PALETTE ||
    169       (color_type == PNG_COLOR_TYPE_GRAY && bit_depth < 8))
    170     png_set_expand(png_ptr);
    171 
    172   // Transparency for paletted images.
    173   if (png_get_valid(png_ptr, info_ptr, PNG_INFO_tRNS))
    174     png_set_expand(png_ptr);
    175 
    176   // Convert 16-bit to 8-bit.
    177   if (bit_depth == 16)
    178     png_set_strip_16(png_ptr);
    179 
    180   // Expand grayscale to RGB.
    181   if (color_type == PNG_COLOR_TYPE_GRAY ||
    182       color_type == PNG_COLOR_TYPE_GRAY_ALPHA)
    183     png_set_gray_to_rgb(png_ptr);
    184 
    185   // Deal with gamma and keep it under our control.
    186   double gamma;
    187   if (png_get_gAMA(png_ptr, info_ptr, &gamma)) {
    188     if (gamma <= 0.0 || gamma > kMaxGamma) {
    189       gamma = kInverseGamma;
    190       png_set_gAMA(png_ptr, info_ptr, gamma);
    191     }
    192     png_set_gamma(png_ptr, kDefaultGamma, gamma);
    193   } else {
    194     png_set_gamma(png_ptr, kDefaultGamma, kInverseGamma);
    195   }
    196 
    197   // Tell libpng to send us rows for interlaced pngs.
    198   if (interlace_type == PNG_INTERLACE_ADAM7)
    199     png_set_interlace_handling(png_ptr);
    200 
    201   // Update our info now
    202   png_read_update_info(png_ptr, info_ptr);
    203   channels = png_get_channels(png_ptr, info_ptr);
    204 
    205   // Pick our row format converter necessary for this data.
    206   if (channels == 3) {
    207     switch (state->output_format) {
    208       case FORMAT_RGB:
    209         state->row_converter = NULL;  // no conversion necessary
    210         state->output_channels = 3;
    211         break;
    212       case FORMAT_RGBA:
    213         state->row_converter = &ConvertRGBtoRGBA;
    214         state->output_channels = 4;
    215         break;
    216       case FORMAT_BGRA:
    217         state->row_converter = &ConvertRGBtoBGRA;
    218         state->output_channels = 4;
    219         break;
    220       default:
    221         NOTREACHED() << "Unknown output format";
    222         break;
    223     }
    224   } else if (channels == 4) {
    225     switch (state->output_format) {
    226       case FORMAT_RGB:
    227         state->row_converter = &ConvertRGBAtoRGB;
    228         state->output_channels = 3;
    229         break;
    230       case FORMAT_RGBA:
    231         state->row_converter = NULL;  // no conversion necessary
    232         state->output_channels = 4;
    233         break;
    234       case FORMAT_BGRA:
    235         state->row_converter = &ConvertBetweenBGRAandRGBA;
    236         state->output_channels = 4;
    237         break;
    238       default:
    239         NOTREACHED() << "Unknown output format";
    240         break;
    241     }
    242   } else {
    243     NOTREACHED() << "Unknown input channels";
    244     longjmp(png_jmpbuf(png_ptr), 1);
    245   }
    246 
    247   state->output->resize(
    248       state->width * state->output_channels * state->height);
    249 }
    250 
    251 void DecodeRowCallback(png_struct* png_ptr, png_byte* new_row,
    252                        png_uint_32 row_num, int pass) {
    253   PngDecoderState* state = static_cast<PngDecoderState*>(
    254       png_get_progressive_ptr(png_ptr));
    255 
    256   DCHECK(pass == 0);
    257   if (static_cast<int>(row_num) > state->height) {
    258     NOTREACHED() << "Invalid row";
    259     return;
    260   }
    261 
    262   unsigned char* base = NULL;
    263   base = &state->output->front();
    264 
    265   unsigned char* dest = &base[state->width * state->output_channels * row_num];
    266   if (state->row_converter)
    267     state->row_converter(new_row, state->width, dest, &state->is_opaque);
    268   else
    269     memcpy(dest, new_row, state->width * state->output_channels);
    270 }
    271 
    272 void DecodeEndCallback(png_struct* png_ptr, png_info* info) {
    273   PngDecoderState* state = static_cast<PngDecoderState*>(
    274       png_get_progressive_ptr(png_ptr));
    275 
    276   // Mark the image as complete, this will tell the Decode function that we
    277   // have successfully found the end of the data.
    278   state->done = true;
    279 }
    280 
    281 // Automatically destroys the given read structs on destruction to make
    282 // cleanup and error handling code cleaner.
    283 class PngReadStructDestroyer {
    284  public:
    285   PngReadStructDestroyer(png_struct** ps, png_info** pi) : ps_(ps), pi_(pi) {
    286   }
    287   ~PngReadStructDestroyer() {
    288     png_destroy_read_struct(ps_, pi_, NULL);
    289   }
    290  private:
    291   png_struct** ps_;
    292   png_info** pi_;
    293 };
    294 
    295 bool BuildPNGStruct(const unsigned char* input, size_t input_size,
    296                     png_struct** png_ptr, png_info** info_ptr) {
    297   if (input_size < 8)
    298     return false;  // Input data too small to be a png
    299 
    300   // Have libpng check the signature, it likes the first 8 bytes.
    301   if (png_sig_cmp(const_cast<unsigned char*>(input), 0, 8) != 0)
    302     return false;
    303 
    304   *png_ptr = png_create_read_struct(PNG_LIBPNG_VER_STRING, NULL, NULL, NULL);
    305   if (!*png_ptr)
    306     return false;
    307 
    308   *info_ptr = png_create_info_struct(*png_ptr);
    309   if (!*info_ptr) {
    310     png_destroy_read_struct(png_ptr, NULL, NULL);
    311     return false;
    312   }
    313 
    314   return true;
    315 }
    316 
    317 }  // namespace
    318 
    319 // static
    320 bool Decode(const unsigned char* input, size_t input_size,
    321                       ColorFormat format, std::vector<unsigned char>* output,
    322                       int* w, int* h) {
    323   png_struct* png_ptr = NULL;
    324   png_info* info_ptr = NULL;
    325   if (!BuildPNGStruct(input, input_size, &png_ptr, &info_ptr))
    326     return false;
    327 
    328   PngReadStructDestroyer destroyer(&png_ptr, &info_ptr);
    329   if (setjmp(png_jmpbuf(png_ptr))) {
    330     // The destroyer will ensure that the structures are cleaned up in this
    331     // case, even though we may get here as a jump from random parts of the
    332     // PNG library called below.
    333     return false;
    334   }
    335 
    336   PngDecoderState state(format, output);
    337 
    338   png_set_progressive_read_fn(png_ptr, &state, &DecodeInfoCallback,
    339                               &DecodeRowCallback, &DecodeEndCallback);
    340   png_process_data(png_ptr,
    341                    info_ptr,
    342                    const_cast<unsigned char*>(input),
    343                    input_size);
    344 
    345   if (!state.done) {
    346     // Fed it all the data but the library didn't think we got all the data, so
    347     // this file must be truncated.
    348     output->clear();
    349     return false;
    350   }
    351 
    352   *w = state.width;
    353   *h = state.height;
    354   return true;
    355 }
    356 
    357 // Encoder --------------------------------------------------------------------
    358 //
    359 // This section of the code is based on nsPNGEncoder.cpp in Mozilla
    360 // (Copyright 2005 Google Inc.)
    361 
    362 namespace {
    363 
    364 // Passed around as the io_ptr in the png structs so our callbacks know where
    365 // to write data.
    366 struct PngEncoderState {
    367   explicit PngEncoderState(std::vector<unsigned char>* o) : out(o) {}
    368   std::vector<unsigned char>* out;
    369 };
    370 
    371 // Called by libpng to flush its internal buffer to ours.
    372 void EncoderWriteCallback(png_structp png, png_bytep data, png_size_t size) {
    373   PngEncoderState* state = static_cast<PngEncoderState*>(png_get_io_ptr(png));
    374   DCHECK(state->out);
    375 
    376   size_t old_size = state->out->size();
    377   state->out->resize(old_size + size);
    378   memcpy(&(*state->out)[old_size], data, size);
    379 }
    380 
    381 void FakeFlushCallback(png_structp png) {
    382   // We don't need to perform any flushing since we aren't doing real IO, but
    383   // we're required to provide this function by libpng.
    384 }
    385 
    386 void ConvertBGRAtoRGB(const unsigned char* bgra, int pixel_width,
    387                       unsigned char* rgb, bool* is_opaque) {
    388   for (int x = 0; x < pixel_width; x++) {
    389     const unsigned char* pixel_in = &bgra[x * 4];
    390     unsigned char* pixel_out = &rgb[x * 3];
    391     pixel_out[0] = pixel_in[2];
    392     pixel_out[1] = pixel_in[1];
    393     pixel_out[2] = pixel_in[0];
    394   }
    395 }
    396 
    397 #ifdef PNG_TEXT_SUPPORTED
    398 
    399 inline char* strdup(const char* str) {
    400 #if defined(OS_WIN)
    401   return _strdup(str);
    402 #else
    403   return ::strdup(str);
    404 #endif
    405 }
    406 
    407 class CommentWriter {
    408  public:
    409   explicit CommentWriter(const std::vector<Comment>& comments)
    410       : comments_(comments),
    411         png_text_(new png_text[comments.size()]) {
    412     for (size_t i = 0; i < comments.size(); ++i)
    413       AddComment(i, comments[i]);
    414   }
    415 
    416   ~CommentWriter() {
    417     for (size_t i = 0; i < comments_.size(); ++i) {
    418       free(png_text_[i].key);
    419       free(png_text_[i].text);
    420     }
    421     delete [] png_text_;
    422   }
    423 
    424   bool HasComments() {
    425     return !comments_.empty();
    426   }
    427 
    428   png_text* get_png_text() {
    429     return png_text_;
    430   }
    431 
    432   int size() {
    433     return static_cast<int>(comments_.size());
    434   }
    435 
    436  private:
    437   void AddComment(size_t pos, const Comment& comment) {
    438     png_text_[pos].compression = PNG_TEXT_COMPRESSION_NONE;
    439     // A PNG comment's key can only be 79 characters long.
    440     DCHECK(comment.key.length() < 79);
    441     png_text_[pos].key = strdup(comment.key.substr(0, 78).c_str());
    442     png_text_[pos].text = strdup(comment.text.c_str());
    443     png_text_[pos].text_length = comment.text.length();
    444 #ifdef PNG_iTXt_SUPPORTED
    445     png_text_[pos].itxt_length = 0;
    446     png_text_[pos].lang = 0;
    447     png_text_[pos].lang_key = 0;
    448 #endif
    449   }
    450 
    451   const std::vector<Comment> comments_;
    452   png_text* png_text_;
    453 };
    454 #endif  // PNG_TEXT_SUPPORTED
    455 
    456 // The type of functions usable for converting between pixel formats.
    457 typedef void (*FormatConverter)(const unsigned char* in, int w,
    458                                 unsigned char* out, bool* is_opaque);
    459 
    460 // libpng uses a wacky setjmp-based API, which makes the compiler nervous.
    461 // We constrain all of the calls we make to libpng where the setjmp() is in
    462 // place to this function.
    463 // Returns true on success.
    464 bool DoLibpngWrite(png_struct* png_ptr, png_info* info_ptr,
    465                    PngEncoderState* state,
    466                    int width, int height, int row_byte_width,
    467                    const unsigned char* input, int compression_level,
    468                    int png_output_color_type, int output_color_components,
    469                    FormatConverter converter,
    470                    const std::vector<Comment>& comments) {
    471 #ifdef PNG_TEXT_SUPPORTED
    472   CommentWriter comment_writer(comments);
    473 #endif
    474   unsigned char* row_buffer = NULL;
    475 
    476   // Make sure to not declare any locals here -- locals in the presence
    477   // of setjmp() in C++ code makes gcc complain.
    478 
    479   if (setjmp(png_jmpbuf(png_ptr))) {
    480     delete[] row_buffer;
    481     return false;
    482   }
    483 
    484   png_set_compression_level(png_ptr, compression_level);
    485 
    486   // Set our callback for libpng to give us the data.
    487   png_set_write_fn(png_ptr, state, EncoderWriteCallback, FakeFlushCallback);
    488 
    489   png_set_IHDR(png_ptr, info_ptr, width, height, 8, png_output_color_type,
    490                PNG_INTERLACE_NONE, PNG_COMPRESSION_TYPE_DEFAULT,
    491                PNG_FILTER_TYPE_DEFAULT);
    492 
    493 #ifdef PNG_TEXT_SUPPORTED
    494   if (comment_writer.HasComments()) {
    495     png_set_text(png_ptr, info_ptr, comment_writer.get_png_text(),
    496                  comment_writer.size());
    497   }
    498 #endif
    499 
    500   png_write_info(png_ptr, info_ptr);
    501 
    502   if (!converter) {
    503     // No conversion needed, give the data directly to libpng.
    504     for (int y = 0; y < height; y ++) {
    505       png_write_row(png_ptr,
    506                     const_cast<unsigned char*>(&input[y * row_byte_width]));
    507     }
    508   } else {
    509     // Needs conversion using a separate buffer.
    510     row_buffer = new unsigned char[width * output_color_components];
    511     for (int y = 0; y < height; y ++) {
    512       converter(&input[y * row_byte_width], width, row_buffer, NULL);
    513       png_write_row(png_ptr, row_buffer);
    514     }
    515     delete[] row_buffer;
    516   }
    517 
    518   png_write_end(png_ptr, info_ptr);
    519   return true;
    520 }
    521 
    522 }  // namespace
    523 
    524 // static
    525 bool EncodeWithCompressionLevel(const unsigned char* input, ColorFormat format,
    526                                 const int width, const int height,
    527                                 int row_byte_width,
    528                                 bool discard_transparency,
    529                                 const std::vector<Comment>& comments,
    530                                 int compression_level,
    531                                 std::vector<unsigned char>* output) {
    532   // Run to convert an input row into the output row format, NULL means no
    533   // conversion is necessary.
    534   FormatConverter converter = NULL;
    535 
    536   int input_color_components, output_color_components;
    537   int png_output_color_type;
    538   switch (format) {
    539     case FORMAT_RGB:
    540       input_color_components = 3;
    541       output_color_components = 3;
    542       png_output_color_type = PNG_COLOR_TYPE_RGB;
    543       discard_transparency = false;
    544       break;
    545 
    546     case FORMAT_RGBA:
    547       input_color_components = 4;
    548       if (discard_transparency) {
    549         output_color_components = 3;
    550         png_output_color_type = PNG_COLOR_TYPE_RGB;
    551         converter = ConvertRGBAtoRGB;
    552       } else {
    553         output_color_components = 4;
    554         png_output_color_type = PNG_COLOR_TYPE_RGB_ALPHA;
    555         converter = NULL;
    556       }
    557       break;
    558 
    559     case FORMAT_BGRA:
    560       input_color_components = 4;
    561       if (discard_transparency) {
    562         output_color_components = 3;
    563         png_output_color_type = PNG_COLOR_TYPE_RGB;
    564         converter = ConvertBGRAtoRGB;
    565       } else {
    566         output_color_components = 4;
    567         png_output_color_type = PNG_COLOR_TYPE_RGB_ALPHA;
    568         converter = ConvertBetweenBGRAandRGBA;
    569       }
    570       break;
    571 
    572     default:
    573       NOTREACHED() << "Unknown pixel format";
    574       return false;
    575   }
    576 
    577   // Row stride should be at least as long as the length of the data.
    578   DCHECK(input_color_components * width <= row_byte_width);
    579 
    580   png_struct* png_ptr = png_create_write_struct(PNG_LIBPNG_VER_STRING,
    581                                                 NULL, NULL, NULL);
    582   if (!png_ptr)
    583     return false;
    584   png_info* info_ptr = png_create_info_struct(png_ptr);
    585   if (!info_ptr) {
    586     png_destroy_write_struct(&png_ptr, NULL);
    587     return false;
    588   }
    589 
    590   PngEncoderState state(output);
    591   bool success = DoLibpngWrite(png_ptr, info_ptr, &state,
    592                                width, height, row_byte_width,
    593                                input, compression_level, png_output_color_type,
    594                                output_color_components, converter, comments);
    595   png_destroy_write_struct(&png_ptr, &info_ptr);
    596 
    597   return success;
    598 }
    599 
    600 // static
    601 bool Encode(const unsigned char* input, ColorFormat format,
    602             const int width, const int height, int row_byte_width,
    603             bool discard_transparency,
    604             const std::vector<Comment>& comments,
    605             std::vector<unsigned char>* output) {
    606   return EncodeWithCompressionLevel(input, format, width, height,
    607                                     row_byte_width,
    608                                     discard_transparency,
    609                                     comments, Z_DEFAULT_COMPRESSION,
    610                                     output);
    611 }
    612 
    613 // Decode a PNG into an RGBA pixel array.
    614 bool DecodePNG(const unsigned char* input, size_t input_size,
    615                std::vector<unsigned char>* output,
    616                int* width, int* height) {
    617   return Decode(input, input_size, FORMAT_RGBA, output, width, height);
    618 }
    619 
    620 // Encode an RGBA pixel array into a PNG.
    621 bool EncodeRGBAPNG(const unsigned char* input,
    622                    int width,
    623                    int height,
    624                    int row_byte_width,
    625                    std::vector<unsigned char>* output) {
    626   return Encode(input, FORMAT_RGBA,
    627       width, height, row_byte_width, false,
    628       std::vector<Comment>(), output);
    629 }
    630 
    631 // Encode an BGRA pixel array into a PNG.
    632 bool EncodeBGRAPNG(const unsigned char* input,
    633                    int width,
    634                    int height,
    635                    int row_byte_width,
    636                    bool discard_transparency,
    637                    std::vector<unsigned char>* output) {
    638   return Encode(input, FORMAT_BGRA,
    639       width, height, row_byte_width, discard_transparency,
    640       std::vector<Comment>(), output);
    641 }
    642 
    643 }  // image_diff_png
    644