Home | History | Annotate | Download | only in util
      1 // Copyright 2013 The Chromium Authors. All rights reserved.
      2 // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
      3 // found in the LICENSE file.
      4 
      5 #include "chrome/installer/util/user_experiment.h"
      6 
      7 #include <windows.h>
      8 #include <sddl.h>
      9 #include <wtsapi32.h>
     10 #include <vector>
     11 
     12 #include "base/command_line.h"
     13 #include "base/files/file_path.h"
     14 #include "base/process/launch.h"
     15 #include "base/rand_util.h"
     16 #include "base/strings/string_number_conversions.h"
     17 #include "base/strings/string_split.h"
     18 #include "base/strings/string_util.h"
     19 #include "base/strings/utf_string_conversions.h"
     20 #include "base/win/scoped_handle.h"
     21 #include "base/win/windows_version.h"
     22 #include "chrome/common/attrition_experiments.h"
     23 #include "chrome/common/chrome_result_codes.h"
     24 #include "chrome/common/chrome_switches.h"
     25 #include "chrome/installer/util/browser_distribution.h"
     26 #include "chrome/installer/util/google_update_constants.h"
     27 #include "chrome/installer/util/google_update_settings.h"
     28 #include "chrome/installer/util/helper.h"
     29 #include "chrome/installer/util/install_util.h"
     30 #include "chrome/installer/util/product.h"
     31 #include "content/public/common/result_codes.h"
     32 
     33 #pragma comment(lib, "wtsapi32.lib")
     34 
     35 namespace installer {
     36 
     37 namespace {
     38 
     39 // The following strings are the possible outcomes of the toast experiment
     40 // as recorded in the |client| field.
     41 const wchar_t kToastExpControlGroup[] =        L"01";
     42 const wchar_t kToastExpCancelGroup[] =         L"02";
     43 const wchar_t kToastExpUninstallGroup[] =      L"04";
     44 const wchar_t kToastExpTriesOkGroup[] =        L"18";
     45 const wchar_t kToastExpTriesErrorGroup[] =     L"28";
     46 const wchar_t kToastActiveGroup[] =            L"40";
     47 const wchar_t kToastUDDirFailure[] =           L"40";
     48 const wchar_t kToastExpBaseGroup[] =           L"80";
     49 
     50 // Substitute the locale parameter in uninstall URL with whatever
     51 // Google Update tells us is the locale. In case we fail to find
     52 // the locale, we use US English.
     53 string16 LocalizeUrl(const wchar_t* url) {
     54   string16 language;
     55   if (!GoogleUpdateSettings::GetLanguage(&language))
     56     language = L"en-US";  // Default to US English.
     57   return ReplaceStringPlaceholders(url, language.c_str(), NULL);
     58 }
     59 
     60 string16 GetWelcomeBackUrl() {
     61   const wchar_t kWelcomeUrl[] = L"http://www.google.com/chrome/intl/$1/"
     62                                 L"welcomeback-new.html";
     63   return LocalizeUrl(kWelcomeUrl);
     64 }
     65 
     66 // Converts FILETIME to hours. FILETIME times are absolute times in
     67 // 100 nanosecond units. For example 5:30 pm of June 15, 2009 is 3580464.
     68 int FileTimeToHours(const FILETIME& time) {
     69   const ULONGLONG k100sNanoSecsToHours = 10000000LL * 60 * 60;
     70   ULARGE_INTEGER uli = {time.dwLowDateTime, time.dwHighDateTime};
     71   return static_cast<int>(uli.QuadPart / k100sNanoSecsToHours);
     72 }
     73 
     74 // Returns the directory last write time in hours since January 1, 1601.
     75 // Returns -1 if there was an error retrieving the directory time.
     76 int GetDirectoryWriteTimeInHours(const wchar_t* path) {
     77   // To open a directory you need to pass FILE_FLAG_BACKUP_SEMANTICS.
     78   DWORD share = FILE_SHARE_READ | FILE_SHARE_WRITE | FILE_SHARE_DELETE;
     79   base::win::ScopedHandle file(::CreateFileW(path, 0, share, NULL,
     80       OPEN_EXISTING, FILE_FLAG_BACKUP_SEMANTICS, NULL));
     81   if (!file.IsValid())
     82     return -1;
     83 
     84   FILETIME time;
     85   return ::GetFileTime(file, NULL, NULL, &time) ? FileTimeToHours(time) : -1;
     86 }
     87 
     88 // Returns the directory last-write time age in hours, relative to current
     89 // time, so if it returns 14 it means that the directory was last written 14
     90 // hours ago. Returns -1 if there was an error retrieving the directory.
     91 int GetDirectoryWriteAgeInHours(const wchar_t* path) {
     92   int dir_time = GetDirectoryWriteTimeInHours(path);
     93   if (dir_time < 0)
     94     return dir_time;
     95   FILETIME time;
     96   GetSystemTimeAsFileTime(&time);
     97   int now_time = FileTimeToHours(time);
     98   if (dir_time >= now_time)
     99     return 0;
    100   return (now_time - dir_time);
    101 }
    102 
    103 // Launches setup.exe (located at |setup_path|) with |cmd_line|.
    104 // If system_level_toast is true, appends --system-level-toast.
    105 // If handle to experiment result key was given at startup, re-add it.
    106 // Does not wait for the process to terminate.
    107 // |cmd_line| may be modified as a result of this call.
    108 bool LaunchSetup(CommandLine* cmd_line, bool system_level_toast) {
    109   const CommandLine& current_cmd_line = *CommandLine::ForCurrentProcess();
    110 
    111   // Propagate --verbose-logging to the invoked setup.exe.
    112   if (current_cmd_line.HasSwitch(switches::kVerboseLogging))
    113     cmd_line->AppendSwitch(switches::kVerboseLogging);
    114 
    115   // Re-add the system level toast flag.
    116   if (system_level_toast) {
    117     cmd_line->AppendSwitch(switches::kSystemLevel);
    118     cmd_line->AppendSwitch(switches::kSystemLevelToast);
    119 
    120     // Re-add the toast result key. We need to do this because Setup running as
    121     // system passes the key to Setup running as user, but that child process
    122     // does not perform the actual toasting, it launches another Setup (as user)
    123     // to do so. That is the process that needs the key.
    124     std::string key(switches::kToastResultsKey);
    125     std::string toast_key = current_cmd_line.GetSwitchValueASCII(key);
    126     if (!toast_key.empty()) {
    127       cmd_line->AppendSwitchASCII(key, toast_key);
    128 
    129       // Use handle inheritance to make sure the duplicated toast results key
    130       // gets inherited by the child process.
    131       base::LaunchOptions options;
    132       options.inherit_handles = true;
    133       return base::LaunchProcess(*cmd_line, options, NULL);
    134     }
    135   }
    136 
    137   return base::LaunchProcess(*cmd_line, base::LaunchOptions(), NULL);
    138 }
    139 
    140 // For System level installs, setup.exe lives in the system temp, which
    141 // is normally c:\windows\temp. In many cases files inside this folder
    142 // are not accessible for execution by regular user accounts.
    143 // This function changes the permissions so that any authenticated user
    144 // can launch |exe| later on. This function should only be called if the
    145 // code is running at the system level.
    146 bool FixDACLsForExecute(const base::FilePath& exe) {
    147   // The general strategy to is to add an ACE to the exe DACL the quick
    148   // and dirty way: a) read the DACL b) convert it to sddl string c) add the
    149   // new ACE to the string d) convert sddl string back to DACL and finally
    150   // e) write new dacl.
    151   char buff[1024];
    152   DWORD len = sizeof(buff);
    153   PSECURITY_DESCRIPTOR sd = reinterpret_cast<PSECURITY_DESCRIPTOR>(buff);
    154   if (!::GetFileSecurityW(exe.value().c_str(), DACL_SECURITY_INFORMATION,
    155                           sd, len, &len)) {
    156     return false;
    157   }
    158   wchar_t* sddl = 0;
    159   if (!::ConvertSecurityDescriptorToStringSecurityDescriptorW(sd,
    160       SDDL_REVISION_1, DACL_SECURITY_INFORMATION, &sddl, NULL))
    161     return false;
    162   string16 new_sddl(sddl);
    163   ::LocalFree(sddl);
    164   sd = NULL;
    165   // See MSDN for the  security descriptor definition language (SDDL) syntax,
    166   // in our case we add "A;" generic read 'GR' and generic execute 'GX' for
    167   // the nt\authenticated_users 'AU' group, that becomes:
    168   const wchar_t kAllowACE[] = L"(A;;GRGX;;;AU)";
    169   // We should check that there are no special ACES for the group we
    170   // are interested, which is nt\authenticated_users.
    171   if (string16::npos != new_sddl.find(L";AU)"))
    172     return false;
    173   // Specific ACEs (not inherited) need to go to the front. It is ok if we
    174   // are the very first one.
    175   size_t pos_insert = new_sddl.find(L"(");
    176   if (string16::npos == pos_insert)
    177     return false;
    178   // All good, time to change the dacl.
    179   new_sddl.insert(pos_insert, kAllowACE);
    180   if (!::ConvertStringSecurityDescriptorToSecurityDescriptorW(new_sddl.c_str(),
    181       SDDL_REVISION_1, &sd, NULL))
    182     return false;
    183   bool rv = ::SetFileSecurityW(exe.value().c_str(), DACL_SECURITY_INFORMATION,
    184                                sd) == TRUE;
    185   ::LocalFree(sd);
    186   return rv;
    187 }
    188 
    189 // This function launches setup as the currently logged-in interactive
    190 // user that is the user whose logon session is attached to winsta0\default.
    191 // It assumes that currently we are running as SYSTEM in a non-interactive
    192 // windowstation.
    193 // The function fails if there is no interactive session active, basically
    194 // the computer is on but nobody has logged in locally.
    195 // Remote Desktop sessions do not count as interactive sessions; running this
    196 // method as a user logged in via remote desktop will do nothing.
    197 bool LaunchSetupAsConsoleUser(CommandLine* cmd_line) {
    198   // Convey to the invoked setup.exe that it's operating on a system-level
    199   // installation.
    200   cmd_line->AppendSwitch(switches::kSystemLevel);
    201 
    202   // Propagate --verbose-logging to the invoked setup.exe.
    203   if (CommandLine::ForCurrentProcess()->HasSwitch(switches::kVerboseLogging))
    204     cmd_line->AppendSwitch(switches::kVerboseLogging);
    205 
    206   // Get the Google Update results key, and pass it on the command line to
    207   // the child process.
    208   int key = GoogleUpdateSettings::DuplicateGoogleUpdateSystemClientKey();
    209   cmd_line->AppendSwitchASCII(switches::kToastResultsKey,
    210                               base::IntToString(key));
    211 
    212   if (base::win::GetVersion() > base::win::VERSION_XP) {
    213     // Make sure that in Vista and Above we have the proper DACLs so
    214     // the interactive user can launch it.
    215     if (!FixDACLsForExecute(cmd_line->GetProgram()))
    216       NOTREACHED();
    217   }
    218 
    219   DWORD console_id = ::WTSGetActiveConsoleSessionId();
    220   if (console_id == 0xFFFFFFFF) {
    221     PLOG(ERROR) << __FUNCTION__ << " failed to get active session id";
    222     return false;
    223   }
    224   HANDLE user_token;
    225   if (!::WTSQueryUserToken(console_id, &user_token)) {
    226     PLOG(ERROR) << __FUNCTION__ << " failed to get user token for console_id "
    227                 << console_id;
    228     return false;
    229   }
    230   // Note: Handle inheritance must be true in order for the child process to be
    231   // able to use the duplicated handle above (Google Update results).
    232   base::LaunchOptions options;
    233   options.as_user = user_token;
    234   options.inherit_handles = true;
    235   options.empty_desktop_name = true;
    236   VLOG(1) << __FUNCTION__ << " launching " << cmd_line->GetCommandLineString();
    237   bool launched = base::LaunchProcess(*cmd_line, options, NULL);
    238   ::CloseHandle(user_token);
    239   VLOG(1) << __FUNCTION__ << "   result: " << launched;
    240   return launched;
    241 }
    242 
    243 // A helper function that writes to HKLM if the handle was passed through the
    244 // command line, but HKCU otherwise. |experiment_group| is the value to write
    245 // and |last_write| is used when writing to HKLM to determine whether to close
    246 // the handle when done.
    247 void SetClient(const string16& experiment_group, bool last_write) {
    248   static int reg_key_handle = -1;
    249   if (reg_key_handle == -1) {
    250     // If a specific Toast Results key handle (presumably to our HKLM key) was
    251     // passed in to the command line (such as for system level installs), we use
    252     // it. Otherwise, we write to the key under HKCU.
    253     const CommandLine& cmd_line = *CommandLine::ForCurrentProcess();
    254     if (cmd_line.HasSwitch(switches::kToastResultsKey)) {
    255       // Get the handle to the key under HKLM.
    256       base::StringToInt(
    257           cmd_line.GetSwitchValueNative(switches::kToastResultsKey),
    258           &reg_key_handle);
    259     } else {
    260       reg_key_handle = 0;
    261     }
    262   }
    263 
    264   if (reg_key_handle) {
    265     // Use it to write the experiment results.
    266     GoogleUpdateSettings::WriteGoogleUpdateSystemClientKey(
    267         reg_key_handle, google_update::kRegClientField, experiment_group);
    268     if (last_write)
    269       CloseHandle((HANDLE) reg_key_handle);
    270   } else {
    271     // Write to HKCU.
    272     GoogleUpdateSettings::SetClient(experiment_group);
    273   }
    274 }
    275 
    276 }  // namespace
    277 
    278 bool CreateExperimentDetails(int flavor, ExperimentDetails* experiment) {
    279   struct FlavorDetails {
    280     int heading_id;
    281     int flags;
    282   };
    283   // Maximum number of experiment flavors we support.
    284   static const int kMax = 4;
    285   // This struct determines which experiment flavors we show for each locale and
    286   // brand.
    287   //
    288   // Plugin infobar experiment:
    289   // The experiment in 2011 used PIxx codes.
    290   //
    291   // Inactive user toast experiment:
    292   // The experiment in Dec 2009 used TGxx and THxx.
    293   // The experiment in Feb 2010 used TKxx and TLxx.
    294   // The experiment in Apr 2010 used TMxx and TNxx.
    295   // The experiment in Oct 2010 used TVxx TWxx TXxx TYxx.
    296   // The experiment in Feb 2011 used SJxx SKxx SLxx SMxx.
    297   // The experiment in Mar 2012 used ZAxx ZBxx ZCxx.
    298   // The experiment in Jan 2013 uses DAxx.
    299   using namespace attrition_experiments;
    300 
    301   static const struct UserExperimentSpecs {
    302     const wchar_t* locale;  // Locale to show this experiment for (* for all).
    303     const wchar_t* brands;  // Brand codes show this experiment for (* for all).
    304     int control_group;      // Size of the control group, in percentages.
    305     const wchar_t* prefix;  // The two letter experiment code. The second letter
    306                             // will be incremented with the flavor.
    307     FlavorDetails flavors[kMax];
    308   } kExperiments[] = {
    309     // The first match from top to bottom is used so this list should be ordered
    310     // most-specific rule first.
    311     { L"*", L"GGRV",  // All locales, GGRV is enterprise.
    312       0,              // 0 percent control group.
    313       L"EA",          // Experiment is EAxx, EBxx, etc.
    314       // No flavors means no experiment.
    315       { { 0, 0 },
    316         { 0, 0 },
    317         { 0, 0 },
    318         { 0, 0 }
    319       }
    320     },
    321     { L"*", L"*",     // All locales, all brands.
    322       5,              // 5 percent control group.
    323       L"DA",          // Experiment is DAxx.
    324       // One single flavor.
    325       { { IDS_TRY_TOAST_HEADING3, kToastUiMakeDefault },
    326         { 0, 0 },
    327         { 0, 0 },
    328         { 0, 0 }
    329       }
    330     }
    331   };
    332 
    333   string16 locale;
    334   GoogleUpdateSettings::GetLanguage(&locale);
    335   if (locale.empty() || (locale == ASCIIToWide("en")))
    336     locale = ASCIIToWide("en-US");
    337 
    338   string16 brand;
    339   if (!GoogleUpdateSettings::GetBrand(&brand))
    340     brand = ASCIIToWide("");  // Could still be viable for catch-all rules.
    341 
    342   for (int i = 0; i < arraysize(kExperiments); ++i) {
    343     if (kExperiments[i].locale != locale &&
    344         kExperiments[i].locale != ASCIIToWide("*"))
    345       continue;
    346 
    347     std::vector<string16> brand_codes;
    348     base::SplitString(kExperiments[i].brands, L',', &brand_codes);
    349     if (brand_codes.empty())
    350       return false;
    351     for (std::vector<string16>::iterator it = brand_codes.begin();
    352          it != brand_codes.end(); ++it) {
    353       if (*it != brand && *it != L"*")
    354         continue;
    355       // We have found our match.
    356       const UserExperimentSpecs& match = kExperiments[i];
    357       // Find out how many flavors we have. Zero means no experiment.
    358       int num_flavors = 0;
    359       while (match.flavors[num_flavors].heading_id) { ++num_flavors; }
    360       if (!num_flavors)
    361         return false;
    362 
    363       if (flavor < 0)
    364         flavor = base::RandInt(0, num_flavors - 1);
    365       experiment->flavor = flavor;
    366       experiment->heading = match.flavors[flavor].heading_id;
    367       experiment->control_group = match.control_group;
    368       const wchar_t prefix[] = { match.prefix[0], match.prefix[1] + flavor, 0 };
    369       experiment->prefix = prefix;
    370       experiment->flags = match.flavors[flavor].flags;
    371       return true;
    372     }
    373   }
    374 
    375   return false;
    376 }
    377 
    378 // Currently we only have one experiment: the inactive user toast. Which only
    379 // applies for users doing upgrades.
    380 
    381 // There are three scenarios when this function is called:
    382 // 1- Is a per-user-install and it updated: perform the experiment
    383 // 2- Is a system-install and it updated : relaunch as the interactive user
    384 // 3- It has been re-launched from the #2 case. In this case we enter
    385 //    this function with |system_install| true and a REENTRY_SYS_UPDATE status.
    386 void LaunchBrowserUserExperiment(const CommandLine& base_cmd_line,
    387                                  InstallStatus status,
    388                                  bool system_level) {
    389   if (system_level) {
    390     if (NEW_VERSION_UPDATED == status) {
    391       CommandLine cmd_line(base_cmd_line);
    392       cmd_line.AppendSwitch(switches::kSystemLevelToast);
    393       // We need to relaunch as the interactive user.
    394       LaunchSetupAsConsoleUser(&cmd_line);
    395       return;
    396     }
    397   } else {
    398     if (status != NEW_VERSION_UPDATED && status != REENTRY_SYS_UPDATE) {
    399       // We are not updating or in re-launch. Exit.
    400       return;
    401     }
    402   }
    403 
    404   // The |flavor| value ends up being processed by TryChromeDialogView to show
    405   // different experiments.
    406   ExperimentDetails experiment;
    407   if (!CreateExperimentDetails(-1, &experiment)) {
    408     VLOG(1) << "Failed to get experiment details.";
    409     return;
    410   }
    411   int flavor = experiment.flavor;
    412   string16 base_group = experiment.prefix;
    413 
    414   string16 brand;
    415   if (GoogleUpdateSettings::GetBrand(&brand) && (brand == L"CHXX")) {
    416     // Testing only: the user automatically qualifies for the experiment.
    417     VLOG(1) << "Experiment qualification bypass";
    418   } else {
    419     // Check that the user was not already drafted in this experiment.
    420     string16 client;
    421     GoogleUpdateSettings::GetClient(&client);
    422     if (client.size() > 2) {
    423       if (base_group == client.substr(0, 2)) {
    424         VLOG(1) << "User already participated in this experiment";
    425         return;
    426       }
    427     }
    428     // Check browser usage inactivity by the age of the last-write time of the
    429     // most recently-used chrome user data directory.
    430     std::vector<base::FilePath> user_data_dirs;
    431     BrowserDistribution* dist = BrowserDistribution::GetSpecificDistribution(
    432         BrowserDistribution::CHROME_BROWSER);
    433     GetChromeUserDataPaths(dist, &user_data_dirs);
    434     int dir_age_hours = -1;
    435     for (size_t i = 0; i < user_data_dirs.size(); ++i) {
    436       int this_age = GetDirectoryWriteAgeInHours(
    437           user_data_dirs[i].value().c_str());
    438       if (this_age >= 0 && (dir_age_hours < 0 || this_age < dir_age_hours))
    439         dir_age_hours = this_age;
    440     }
    441 
    442     const bool experiment_enabled = false;
    443     const int kThirtyDays = 30 * 24;
    444 
    445     if (!experiment_enabled) {
    446       VLOG(1) << "Toast experiment is disabled.";
    447       return;
    448     } else if (dir_age_hours < 0) {
    449       // This means that we failed to find the user data dir. The most likely
    450       // cause is that this user has not ever used chrome at all which can
    451       // happen in a system-level install.
    452       SetClient(base_group + kToastUDDirFailure, true);
    453       return;
    454     } else if (dir_age_hours < kThirtyDays) {
    455       // An active user, so it does not qualify.
    456       VLOG(1) << "Chrome used in last " << dir_age_hours << " hours";
    457       SetClient(base_group + kToastActiveGroup, true);
    458       return;
    459     }
    460     // Check to see if this user belongs to the control group.
    461     double control_group = 1.0 * (100 - experiment.control_group) / 100;
    462     if (base::RandDouble() > control_group) {
    463       SetClient(base_group + kToastExpControlGroup, true);
    464       VLOG(1) << "User is control group";
    465       return;
    466     }
    467   }
    468 
    469   VLOG(1) << "User drafted for toast experiment " << flavor;
    470   SetClient(base_group + kToastExpBaseGroup, false);
    471   // User level: The experiment needs to be performed in a different process
    472   // because google_update expects the upgrade process to be quick and nimble.
    473   // System level: We have already been relaunched, so we don't need to be
    474   // quick, but we relaunch to follow the exact same codepath.
    475   CommandLine cmd_line(base_cmd_line);
    476   cmd_line.AppendSwitchASCII(switches::kInactiveUserToast,
    477                              base::IntToString(flavor));
    478   cmd_line.AppendSwitchASCII(switches::kExperimentGroup,
    479                              WideToASCII(base_group));
    480   LaunchSetup(&cmd_line, system_level);
    481 }
    482 
    483 // User qualifies for the experiment. To test, use --try-chrome-again=|flavor|
    484 // as a parameter to chrome.exe.
    485 void InactiveUserToastExperiment(int flavor,
    486                                  const string16& experiment_group,
    487                                  const Product& product,
    488                                  const base::FilePath& application_path) {
    489   // Add the 'welcome back' url for chrome to show.
    490   CommandLine options(CommandLine::NO_PROGRAM);
    491   options.AppendSwitchNative(::switches::kTryChromeAgain,
    492       base::IntToString16(flavor));
    493   // Prepend the url with a space.
    494   string16 url(GetWelcomeBackUrl());
    495   options.AppendArg("--");
    496   options.AppendArgNative(url);
    497   // The command line should now have the url added as:
    498   // "chrome.exe -- <url>"
    499   DCHECK_NE(string16::npos,
    500       options.GetCommandLineString().find(L" -- " + url));
    501 
    502   // Launch chrome now. It will show the toast UI.
    503   int32 exit_code = 0;
    504   if (!product.LaunchChromeAndWait(application_path, options, &exit_code))
    505     return;
    506 
    507   // The chrome process has exited, figure out what happened.
    508   const wchar_t* outcome = NULL;
    509   switch (exit_code) {
    510     case content::RESULT_CODE_NORMAL_EXIT:
    511       outcome = kToastExpTriesOkGroup;
    512       break;
    513     case chrome::RESULT_CODE_NORMAL_EXIT_CANCEL:
    514       outcome = kToastExpCancelGroup;
    515       break;
    516     case chrome::RESULT_CODE_NORMAL_EXIT_EXP2:
    517       outcome = kToastExpUninstallGroup;
    518       break;
    519     default:
    520       outcome = kToastExpTriesErrorGroup;
    521   };
    522   // Write to the |client| key for the last time.
    523   SetClient(experiment_group + outcome, true);
    524 
    525   if (outcome != kToastExpUninstallGroup)
    526     return;
    527   // The user wants to uninstall. This is a best effort operation. Note that
    528   // we waited for chrome to exit so the uninstall would not detect chrome
    529   // running.
    530   bool system_level_toast = CommandLine::ForCurrentProcess()->HasSwitch(
    531       switches::kSystemLevelToast);
    532 
    533   CommandLine cmd(InstallUtil::GetChromeUninstallCmd(
    534                       system_level_toast, product.distribution()->GetType()));
    535   base::LaunchProcess(cmd, base::LaunchOptions(), NULL);
    536 }
    537 
    538 }  // namespace installer
    539