Home | History | Annotate | Download | only in PowerPC
      1 //===- README_ALTIVEC.txt - Notes for improving Altivec code gen ----------===//
      2 
      3 Implement PPCInstrInfo::isLoadFromStackSlot/isStoreToStackSlot for vector
      4 registers, to generate better spill code.
      5 
      6 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
      7 
      8 The first should be a single lvx from the constant pool, the second should be 
      9 a xor/stvx:
     10 
     11 void foo(void) {
     12   int x[8] __attribute__((aligned(128))) = { 1, 1, 1, 17, 1, 1, 1, 1 };
     13   bar (x);
     14 }
     15 
     16 #include <string.h>
     17 void foo(void) {
     18   int x[8] __attribute__((aligned(128)));
     19   memset (x, 0, sizeof (x));
     20   bar (x);
     21 }
     22 
     23 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     24 
     25 Altivec: Codegen'ing MUL with vector FMADD should add -0.0, not 0.0:
     26 http://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=8763
     27 
     28 When -ffast-math is on, we can use 0.0.
     29 
     30 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     31 
     32   Consider this:
     33   v4f32 Vector;
     34   v4f32 Vector2 = { Vector.X, Vector.X, Vector.X, Vector.X };
     35 
     36 Since we know that "Vector" is 16-byte aligned and we know the element offset 
     37 of ".X", we should change the load into a lve*x instruction, instead of doing
     38 a load/store/lve*x sequence.
     39 
     40 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     41 
     42 For functions that use altivec AND have calls, we are VRSAVE'ing all call
     43 clobbered regs.
     44 
     45 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     46 
     47 Implement passing vectors by value into calls and receiving them as arguments.
     48 
     49 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     50 
     51 GCC apparently tries to codegen { C1, C2, Variable, C3 } as a constant pool load
     52 of C1/C2/C3, then a load and vperm of Variable.
     53 
     54 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     55 
     56 We need a way to teach tblgen that some operands of an intrinsic are required to
     57 be constants.  The verifier should enforce this constraint.
     58 
     59 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     60 
     61 We currently codegen SCALAR_TO_VECTOR as a store of the scalar to a 16-byte
     62 aligned stack slot, followed by a load/vperm.  We should probably just store it
     63 to a scalar stack slot, then use lvsl/vperm to load it.  If the value is already
     64 in memory this is a big win.
     65 
     66 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     67 
     68 extract_vector_elt of an arbitrary constant vector can be done with the 
     69 following instructions:
     70 
     71 vTemp = vec_splat(v0,2);    // 2 is the element the src is in.
     72 vec_ste(&destloc,0,vTemp);
     73 
     74 We can do an arbitrary non-constant value by using lvsr/perm/ste.
     75 
     76 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     77 
     78 If we want to tie instruction selection into the scheduler, we can do some
     79 constant formation with different instructions.  For example, we can generate
     80 "vsplti -1" with "vcmpequw R,R" and 1,1,1,1 with "vsubcuw R,R", and 0,0,0,0 with
     81 "vsplti 0" or "vxor", each of which use different execution units, thus could
     82 help scheduling.
     83 
     84 This is probably only reasonable for a post-pass scheduler.
     85 
     86 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
     87 
     88 For this function:
     89 
     90 void test(vector float *A, vector float *B) {
     91   vector float C = (vector float)vec_cmpeq(*A, *B);
     92   if (!vec_any_eq(*A, *B))
     93     *B = (vector float){0,0,0,0};
     94   *A = C;
     95 }
     96 
     97 we get the following basic block:
     98 
     99 	...
    100         lvx v2, 0, r4
    101         lvx v3, 0, r3
    102         vcmpeqfp v4, v3, v2
    103         vcmpeqfp. v2, v3, v2
    104         bne cr6, LBB1_2 ; cond_next
    105 
    106 The vcmpeqfp/vcmpeqfp. instructions currently cannot be merged when the
    107 vcmpeqfp. result is used by a branch.  This can be improved.
    108 
    109 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
    110 
    111 The code generated for this is truly aweful:
    112 
    113 vector float test(float a, float b) {
    114  return (vector float){ 0.0, a, 0.0, 0.0}; 
    115 }
    116 
    117 LCPI1_0:                                        ;  float
    118         .space  4
    119         .text
    120         .globl  _test
    121         .align  4
    122 _test:
    123         mfspr r2, 256
    124         oris r3, r2, 4096
    125         mtspr 256, r3
    126         lis r3, ha16(LCPI1_0)
    127         addi r4, r1, -32
    128         stfs f1, -16(r1)
    129         addi r5, r1, -16
    130         lfs f0, lo16(LCPI1_0)(r3)
    131         stfs f0, -32(r1)
    132         lvx v2, 0, r4
    133         lvx v3, 0, r5
    134         vmrghw v3, v3, v2
    135         vspltw v2, v2, 0
    136         vmrghw v2, v2, v3
    137         mtspr 256, r2
    138         blr
    139 
    140 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
    141 
    142 int foo(vector float *x, vector float *y) {
    143         if (vec_all_eq(*x,*y)) return 3245; 
    144         else return 12;
    145 }
    146 
    147 A predicate compare being used in a select_cc should have the same peephole
    148 applied to it as a predicate compare used by a br_cc.  There should be no
    149 mfcr here:
    150 
    151 _foo:
    152         mfspr r2, 256
    153         oris r5, r2, 12288
    154         mtspr 256, r5
    155         li r5, 12
    156         li r6, 3245
    157         lvx v2, 0, r4
    158         lvx v3, 0, r3
    159         vcmpeqfp. v2, v3, v2
    160         mfcr r3, 2
    161         rlwinm r3, r3, 25, 31, 31
    162         cmpwi cr0, r3, 0
    163         bne cr0, LBB1_2 ; entry
    164 LBB1_1: ; entry
    165         mr r6, r5
    166 LBB1_2: ; entry
    167         mr r3, r6
    168         mtspr 256, r2
    169         blr
    170 
    171 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
    172 
    173 CodeGen/PowerPC/vec_constants.ll has an and operation that should be
    174 codegen'd to andc.  The issue is that the 'all ones' build vector is
    175 SelectNodeTo'd a VSPLTISB instruction node before the and/xor is selected
    176 which prevents the vnot pattern from matching.
    177 
    178 
    179 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
    180 
    181 An alternative to the store/store/load approach for illegal insert element 
    182 lowering would be:
    183 
    184 1. store element to any ol' slot
    185 2. lvx the slot
    186 3. lvsl 0; splat index; vcmpeq to generate a select mask
    187 4. lvsl slot + x; vperm to rotate result into correct slot
    188 5. vsel result together.
    189 
    190 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
    191 
    192 Should codegen branches on vec_any/vec_all to avoid mfcr.  Two examples:
    193 
    194 #include <altivec.h>
    195  int f(vector float a, vector float b)
    196  {
    197   int aa = 0;
    198   if (vec_all_ge(a, b))
    199     aa |= 0x1;
    200   if (vec_any_ge(a,b))
    201     aa |= 0x2;
    202   return aa;
    203 }
    204 
    205 vector float f(vector float a, vector float b) { 
    206   if (vec_any_eq(a, b)) 
    207     return a; 
    208   else 
    209     return b; 
    210 }
    211 
    212